Saturday, January 18, 2025

Colm Tóibín: Nora Webster (2014)




I'm not at all satisfied with the little I've been able to say of Nora Webster, a scant testament to how deeply I've taken up residence in it. 

So it's pleasing to supply a link to this piece by Gregory Day in the Sydney Review of Books, somewhat disputable, but which gets much closer to where I would have liked to go:

https://sydneyreviewofbooks.com/reviews/the-submerged-moon-nora-webster-by-colm-toibin


And for its acuteness and accuracy I'd also recommend Kelly McMaster's review in the Columbia Magazine:

https://magazine.columbia.edu/article/book-review-nora-webster


*


Nora Webster, recently bereaved, is visiting her sister Catherine's house. 


They went to bed early. Nora was glad to be away from them and from the talk of auctions and big houses and new washing machines. It was clear to her that there was nothing she could have spoken to Catherine and Dilly about, nothing that would have interested her or them. When she asked herself what she was interested in, she had to conclude that she was interested in nothing at all. What mattered to her now could be shared with no one. Jim and Margaret had been with her when Maurice died, and that meant that all three of them could talk easily when Jim and Margaret came to the house because, while they did not refer to those days in the hospital, what they went through then underlay every word they said. It was there with them in the same way as the air was in the room, it was so present that no one ever commented on it. For them now conversation was a way of managing things. But for Catherine and Dilly and Mark conversation was normal. She wondered if she would ever again be able to have a normal conversation and what topics she might be able to discuss with ease and interest. 

At the moment the only topic she could discuss was herself. And everyone, she felt, had heard enough about her. They believed it was time that she stop brooding and think of other things. But there were no other things. There was only what had happened. It was as though she lived under water and had given up on the struggle to swim towards air. It would be too much. Being released into the world of others seemed impossible; it was something she did not even want. How could she explain this to anyone who sought to know how she was or asked if she was getting over what happened?

She woke early in the morning, dreading the day ahead. She wondered if the boys felt like this too. Did Fiona and Aine also dread the day ahead when they woke? Jim and Margaret? Perhaps, she thought, they had found other things to preoccupy them. She, too, could find other things to think about -- money, for example, or her children, or the job in Gibney's. Finding things to think about was not the problem for her; the problem for her was that she was on her own now and that she had no idea how to live. She would have to learn, but it was a mistake to try to do so in someone else's house. It was a mistake to lie here in a strange bed when her own bed at home was strange too. The strangeness of home, however, did not require a bright response from her. It would be a long time, she thought, before she would leave her own house for a night again. 

(Nora Webster, Ch 4)


Margaret, because she worked for the County Council, earned more money than Jim and had even fewer needs. Paying for Aine's school and giving pocket money to Fiona and the boys pleased her, gave her a stake in how they lived and what they planned to do in the future. It amused Nora, as they sat down to eat, to watch Fiona describing the cultural sights of London with her aunt and uncle rather than Saturday stalls and cheap clothes shops. Fiona had been to a Shakespeare play in which some of the actors had been in the audience and had jumped up at the most unexpected moments.

'How d-did you know they were actors?' Donal asked. 

'That's exactly what I was going to ask,' Margaret said. 

'They were in costume and they knew their lines,' Fiona said. 'But it was a big shock when they stood up.'

'Well, I hope that doesn't catch on,' Margaret said. 'Then you would never know where you were. The man beside you could be the Bull McCabe.'

(Nora Webster, Ch 6)

[Bull McCabe was the tough protagonist in John B Keane's The Field, a rural drama first performed in 1965.]

Nora Webster is so many things. It's a world we live within, once we learn to read its plainness of expression. It's one of the most complete modern novels I've read, but one that shines least in quotations. I shouldn't worry, it has found its way to plenty of readers, and I'm just happy that one of them is me. 

It uses chiaroscuro to striking effect. First impressions may be that the reader is assaulted with a multiplicity of names. And it's true; the novel draws near, quite deliberately, to the ordinary café talk that we sometimes overhear and find incomprehensible, and also to the genre of popular family sagas. 

"She knew the story of her life down to her maiden name", Nora reflects about May Lacey, a fellow townswoman who has never been to her house before (p. 3). But to give us a thrilling sense of sharing the immense network of knowledge in any ordinary existence, the author must not plod, but paradoxically must be highly selective: throw intense light here and here, leave the rest in suggestive shadow... The exercise of working out Nora's family tree (see below) shows that the novel is actually distinctly selective in the names it chucks at us. We never learn Nora's own maiden name. We never learn the names of her mother or father. We never learn the names of her sister Catherine's children, or even how many there are. Nora hasn't much interest in these nephews and nieces, we infer; nor in her cousin John (whose wife is simply called "John's wife"). But as for her mother and father it's the opposite inference: they mean so much to her that her thoughts would never distance them by using a name. 

*


The novel is written strictly from Nora's point of view, which brings us to other chasms. She often becomes aware that her sons share some secret, or that her daughters have been saying something about her, but these mysteries are not to be solved, just briefly wondered about, like the way you wonder about the reason for something in nature, but know you'll never trouble to find out. 

The sea [at Curracloe] was rougher than she ever remembered it. She wondered if there was more shelter at Cush  and if the waves there broke more gently. Also, the strand there was shorter and there were stones at the edge of the shore. Here there were sand dunes and the long strand, no stones, no shelter, no cliffs made of marl ... (p. 179)

The wondering fades away with the events of the day. For instance when the boys are playing about on the lifts in Arnott's. They are away so long that she starts to worry.

When they found her, they pretended it was nothing, that the lift had merely stopped at every floor. When she told them that she had thought they were lost, they gave each other a look as though something had happened to them in the lift that they did not want her to know about. (p. 20)

The bereaved Nora remembers her time with Maurice as idyllic and no doubt this was basically true but not all there was to it. Perhaps being married to Nora wasn't always plain sailing. Perhaps Maurice who was so personable (her buffer against being exposed to society or needing to have her own opinions) was also often opinionated and ignorant (e.g. about musical life, p. 204). Maurice strongly disapproved of Nora's anonymous letters to Sister Agnes (p. 233). There must have been the usual marital arguments. 

Other people, including some of her own family, treat her with a certain caution: as if Nora was felt to be rather a difficult prickly person. She was a demon before she met Maurice, says Catherine (p. 301). Nora is notably sharp-witted and sharp-tongued, outwardly or internally: in particular about other women, including her own sisters and daughters. (You can see a certain family resemblance to her aunt Josie.)

There were also times her own family  repeatedly relished her discomfort (p. 205); perhaps they were not exactly angels even in the hallowed past. On the whole, we guess, they were a reasonably normal family.

*

Nora never got the chance of a university education. Her imagination and interests are local and very mainstream. She reads novels mainly to switch off, she watches the news on TV, she reads newspapers. 

(But readers who read in the same way as Nora have often been disappointed by Nora Webster, as its Amazon reviews voluminously testify.)

The novel delights in capturing the ordinariness of her thoughts. It makes us take these ordinary thoughts seriously. Her life, we see, is culturally rich though it isn't full of  the arts (high or low) or studious abstract thinking. A film (like Gaslight) or music (the Archduke trio) can suddenly produce a deep response in her, but she doesn't live for these moments.

You can hear Nora's voice in the above conversation about the actors: "the cultural sights of London" and "at the most unexpected moments".. Or

Nora could not think why Nancy was telling her all of this as though it were urgent and fascinating news. (p. 157)

When Aine's Leaving Cert results came, they could not have been better and this meant that Aine would be going to University College Dublin. (p. 188)

Those mundane expressions make us warm to her because we recognize them as like ours and like those of people we love. Nora's thoughts are audible in the prose, often signalled by this mundanity. Nora is a kind of narrator, as everyone else is, in her internal thoughts. She is driven to put a shape on her experience, and sometimes we can hear her preparing the expressions she would use to narrate it, should anyone ask. She is a pretty honest narrator to herself, not markedly self-deceiving, but she's still unreliable because there's so much about her own life and about Enniscorthy life that she will never know. 


*


Some things Nora doesn't know: 

What she seems like to other people (something she often speculates about). The intensity of her grief apparently blares out though her own thoughts are apt to understate it.

Why it was that she herself didn't contact her boys for such a long time when Maurice was dying. 

And what precipitated Donal's stammer.

And what he sees in photography.

And the photos he never shows her. (And she never asks to see?)

The other side of the bullying office manager Francie Kavanagh, attested to by Sister Thomas and the young bookkeeper. 

What happened when Laurie O'Keefe's picture changed (p. 204).

Is the appearance of Maurice her own imagination or something real?

Who is "the other one" mentioned by Maurice (p. 294). 


*

Dates. The action of Nora Webster occupies about five years, from October 1967 to Summer 1972. (No year dates are mentioned, but they can be worked out from public events.)

One of the incidental joys of the novel is its realization of provincial Ireland during this specific historical era. The first two years occupy about seven chapters each. The next three years occupy just four chapters. 

Ch 1  October 1967.

Ch 2 January 1968

Ch 3-5 Six months after Maurice's death. If he died in August 1967 that would make it February 1968. 

Ch 6 Working at Gibney's. Spring 1968

Ch 7 Summer 1968. Then, p. 113: The riot and baton charge in Derry. It is 5th October, 1968. 

Ch 8 October 1968

Ch 9 Late October 1968 to Christmas 1968 (p. 138-40).

Ch 10 March 1969 (p. 144). 

Ch 11 subsequent weeks...

Ch 12 The quiz night. May 1969?

Ch 13 Summer holiday: July 1969. (The landing on the moon took place late on Sunday July 20 GMT, the moonwalk in the early hours of Monday July 21st GMT). Later Aine and Donal follow the riots in Derry and Belfast (mid August 1969). Fiona visits London for a few days at the end of the summer.

Ch 14. Music lessons. From September 1969 and the next few months?

Ch 15. May 1970 (Haughey's arrest for gunrunning). The holiday in Sitges, in the first two weeks of September 1970, followed by Conor being put in the B class. Goes through to February 1971 (Aine on TV).

Ch 16. Goes through to early summer (1971), late July (p. 250), September (p. 252) when Donal starts at St Peter's. 

Ch 17. Christmas 1971. January 1972. Bloody Sunday (30th January 1972) (p. 263). British Embassy attacked 2 February 1972 (p. 265) -- the episode where Aine goes missing. Late February (p. 274): Nora gets interested in doing up the house. Painting the ceiling (April 1972?).

Ch 18. No dates are mentioned but it follows on. Summer 1972, basically. 


*



Nora's family:

Maurice, a teacher, has recently died. Aunt Josie looked after the boys while Nora nursed Maurice in his last months. Aine was at home with Una looking after her (and Fiona visiting them regularly). 

Josie was a teacher until she retired. 

Nora's father died when she was 14, Nora was alone with him. Nora was her father's favourite, Josie says (p.34).

Nora's mother had once been a servant girl at a farm (p. 62), later worked in Cullen's (p.63). She was a good singer.  She had a small shop (p. 50). Nora's mother died when Nora already had children; it was seven years before Maurice died (p. 196) i.e. about 1960. Nora didn't love her mother when she was alive, there was coldness between them (p. 196) and Josie thinks her mother didn't know what to do with her (p. 34). 

Both Nora's grandmothers died before she was born (p. 284)

Neither Jim nor Margaret have ever married, they live together in the old family home. Jim is 15 years older than Maurice. 

Maurice and Jim learnt Irish in the Kerry Gaeltacht forty years ago (p. 105).

Maurice had another "delicate" brother, who died (p. 167) of TB (p. 301). 

Maurice had a cousin called Aidan (p. 169)

Maurice's grandfather was evicted from his farm for political activity. Aine's politics came from her Webster side, according to Aunt Josie (p. 299). [NB  Aine is pronounced something like Ahn-yuh.]

Aunt Mary is mentioned on p. 284.

In the course of the novel, Una becomes engaged to Seamus.


*

Nora Webster runs parallel to major events in Colm Tóibín's youth. His own father Mícheál died in 1967 (like Maurice). The novel is in memory of his mother Bríd (d. 2000) and his younger brother Niall (who died in 2004, aged just 44); they are (and aren't) the characters Nora and Conor; Colm himself is (and isn't) Donal. 

About his mother, and much more: this great interview with Kathy Sheridan in the Irish Times:

https://www.irishtimes.com/culture/books/colm-toibin-i-start-and-i-finish-1.1943080

*

Nora's car is an old Austin A40 at the start, but an old Morris Minor in the recent past. Perhaps an error? (The car on the jacket image is neither, as far as I can make out.)

*

"Too young to die, they say. Too young? No, rather he is blessed in being so young thus to be made swiftly an immortal. He has escaped the tremulous hands of age." (p. 47)

The quotation that Nora wants on the memorial card (given more fully on p. 51) is by the English Dominican Bede Jarrett (The House of Gold: Lenten Sermons (1931)).

Nora reads it again, and 

The words, she thought, seemed to be too certain. Wherever Maurice was at this moment, he would long for the comfort of this house and for her, as much as she longed for the past year of her life to be wiped away and for him to return to them. 

(p. 51)

It's possible to trace, or suppose we trace, Nora's feelings on this topic through the novel: from this early rawness through to "He has not been watching over me!" (p. 126) and eventually to her letting go of the past. 


*

On Colm Tóibín's The Master (2004):

On Colm Tóibín's The Heather Blazing (1992):


Labels:

Monday, January 06, 2025

Reading around Colm Tóibín: The Master (2004)

Terracotta bust of the twelve-year-old Count Alberto Bevilacqua by Hendrik Christian Andersen. Purchased by Henry James for Lamb House, Rye.



[Image source: https://jasoncochran.com/2014/04/29/henry-james-muses-the-bust-in-his-dining-room-and-a-sort-of-secret-dynasty/ .]


 

 ... For his friends, this night would be entered into the annals of the unmentionable, pages in which he had so studiously avoided having his name appear. As time passed, however, he realized that he could not betray the performers now. He could not give into his own horrible urge to be alone in the darkness, to escape into the night and walk as though he had written nothing and was nobody. He would have to go to them and thank them; he would have to insist that the repast planned after the triumph of his play should go ahead. In the half light he stood preparing himself, steeling himself, ready to suppress whatever his own urges and needs might be. He made his hands into fists as he set out to smile and bow and imagine that the evening in all its glory had been due entirely to the talents of the actors in the great tradition of the London stage. 

(From Colm Tóibín's The Master, end of Ch 1 (January 1895).)

*

That final sentence is a little miracle; Tóibín showing us Henry's distressed thoughts preparing for verbiage; the nonsense he must say at the after-show party, so begins to imagine. 

The Master is the wonderful portrait of an artistic freedom gone rogue. The more desperately Henry needs to preserve his freedom, the more he must confine his life and his thoughts. The more uncompromising he needs to be, the more he must compromise. It's a trade-off that's almost ruinous, to his life and to his art. Almost. 

Like many of his stories, Guy Domville was helplessly personal in its accent on renunciation of marriage. Guy's willingness to marry is as lightly thrown off as it was assumed; it seems evident that he adores Mrs Peverel only as a mother-figure.

*

GUY. What I must forget is that I've strayed! -- From the happiness that was near to the happiness that was far! 

MRS. PEVEREL. But the happiness that was "near" was a life you had put away.

GUY. The happiness that was near was a treasure not mine to touch! I believed that treasure then to be another's.

MRS. PEVEREL. You had too great things to think of -- and now I see how they've changed you. You hold yourself in another way. 

GUY. (Smiling.) I try to carry my "name"!

MRS. PEVEREL. (Triumphant, to prove how right she has been.) You carry it better than you did!

GUY. People have cried me up for it. But the better the name, the better the man should be.

MRS. PEVEREL. He can't be better than when his duty prevails. 

GUY. Sometimes that duty is darkened, and then it shines again! It lighted my way as I came, and it's bright in my eyes at this hour. But the brightness, in truth, is yours -- it grows and grows in your presence. Better than anything I sought or found is that purer passion -- this calm retreat! (Then on an ironic movement of MRS. PEVEREL'S.) Aye, calm, Madam (struck with the sight of LORD DEVENISH'S white gloves), save for these! I've seen them before -- I've touched them. (Thinking, recalling; then with light breaking.) At Richmond!

MRS. PEVEREL. (Deeply discomposed, at a loss.) My Lord Devenish left them.

GUY. (Astounded.) Was he here?

(From Guy Domville, Act III.)

Complete English text of Guy Domville, alongside a 2012 Portuguese translation by Mônica Zardo (PDF):

https://lume.ufrgs.br/bitstream/10183/66289/1/000870716.pdf

*

Guy Domville is set in 1780. The sets and costumes were designed accordingly (with mixed success), but Henry James took no great interest in the date he had specified. The characters speak modern Jamesian. Guy does indeed arrive in a "shay", that is, a chaise, a vehicle going out of use by the mid 19th century. But "shay" is American slang, perhaps recalled from "The Deacon's Masterpiece", a popular poem by Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr. 

*

Henry was so agitated on the opening night at St James's Theatre (5 January 1895) that he knew he must keep away. He walked up the street to the Haymarket to see Oscar Wilde's An Ideal Husband (which had opened two days before) returning to his own play only for its final lines and the catcalls. Seeing Wilde's play had made him feel worse; not only was it trash (Henry considered most plays to be trash), it had "smash hit" written all over it. 


LORD GORING. Come in there, father. Your sneezes are quite heartrending.

LORD CAVERSHAM. Well, sir, I suppose I have a right to sneeze when I choose?

LORD GORING. [Apologetically.] Quite so, father. I was merely expressing sympathy.

LORD CAVERSHAM. Oh, damn sympathy. There is a great deal too much of that sort of thing going on nowadays.

LORD GORING. I quite agree with you, father. If there was less sympathy in the world there would be less trouble in the world.

LORD CAVERSHAM. [Going towards the smoking-room.] That is a paradox, sir. I hate paradoxes.

LORD GORING. So do I, father. Everybody one meets is a paradox nowadays. It is a great bore. It makes society so obvious.

LORD CAVERSHAM. [Turning round, and looking at his son beneath his bushy eyebrows.] Do you always really understand what you say, sir?

LORD GORING. [After some hesitation.] Yes, father, if I listen attentively.


Complete text of An Ideal Husband:

https://www.gutenberg.org/files/885/885-h/885-h.htm

*

Hendrik Christian Andersen and John Briggs Potter in Florence, 1894 painting by Andreas Martin Andersen.

[Image source: Wikimedia Commons .]

The painting has been given various interpretations: the homoeroticism seems blatant and yet is conceivably a figment. The same might be said of the scene in The Master from Henry's youth, when he spends a night in a single bed with Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr, both of them naked. [This was the Holmes who was later a US Supreme Court justice and proponent of eugenics.]

In the novel that formative scene, young Henry being cupped by Holmes' body, is quietly recalled much later in Andersen's sympathetic embrace of the older Henry in the Protestant cemetery in Rome (a scene, by the way, that also contains a cat who wants to be stroked). 

*

Henry in the Protestant cemetery is overcome before the recent tomb of his friend, the author Constance Fenimore Woolson, who committed suicide in Venice in 1894. (Was she another, the novel asks, who made the fatal mistake of pinning her hopes on Henry?)

Anyway, she had her own comment on art without compromise, when the obscure heroine of "Miss Grief" asks a successful author to read her play. 

I followed up my advantage, opened the little paper volume and began. I first took the drama line by line, and spoke of the faults of expression and structure; then I turned back and touched upon two or three glaring impossibilities in the plot. "Your absorbed interest in the motive of the whole no doubt made you forget these blemishes," I said apologetically.

But, to my surprise, I found that she did not see the blemishes—that she appreciated nothing I had said, comprehended nothing. Such unaccountable obtuseness puzzled me. I began again, going over the whole with even greater minuteness and care. I worked hard: the perspiration stood in beads upon my forehead as I struggled with her—what shall I call it—obstinacy? But it was not exactly obstinacy. She simply could not see the faults of her own work, any more than a blind man can see the smoke that dims a patch of blue sky. When I had finished my task the second time she still remained as gently impassive as before. I leaned back in my chair exhausted, and looked at her.

Even then she did not seem to comprehend (whether she agreed with it or not) what I must be thinking. "It is such a heaven to me that you like it!" she murmured dreamily, breaking the silence. Then, with more animation, "And now you will let me recite it?"

I was too weary to oppose her; she threw aside her shawl and bonnet, and, standing in the centre of the room, began.

And she carried me along with her: all the strong passages were doubly strong when spoken, and the faults, which seemed nothing to her, were made by her earnestness to seem nothing to me, at least for that moment. When it was ended she stood looking at me with a triumphant smile.

"Yes," I said, "I like it, and you see that I do. But I like it because my taste is peculiar. To me originality and force are everything—perhaps because I have them not to any marked degree myself—but the world at large will not overlook as I do your absolutely barbarous shortcomings on account of them. Will you trust me to go over the drama and correct it at my pleasure?" This was a vast deal for me to offer; I was surprised at myself.

"No," she answered softly, still smiling. "There shall not be so much as a comma altered." Then she sat down and fell into a reverie as though she were alone.

(From "Miss Grief".)

Woolson's writings are available on Project Gutenberg, so I've read a few of her stories. The most challenging was "King David", a brazenly racist assault on northern do-gooders (and their own inner racism), anticipating Stephen Crane. Her writing responded more warmly to the American South than anywhere else, I think. 

As soon as they could speak, "Where are the two out in the sail-boat?" asked the Sister.

"God knows!" answered Melvyna. "The last time I noticed their sail they were about a mile outside of the reef."

"I will go and see."

"Go and see! Are you crazy? You can never get through that water."

"The saints would help me, I think," said the little Sister.

She had risen, and now stood regarding the watery waste with the usual timid look in her gentle eyes. Then she stepped forward with her uncertain tread, and before the woman by her side comprehended her purpose she was gone, ankle-deep in the tide, knee-deep, and finally wading across the sand up to her waist in water toward the lighthouse. The great wave was no deeper, however, even there. She waded to the door of the tower, opened it with difficulty, climbed the stairway, and gained the light-room, where the glass of the windows was all shattered, and the little chamber half full of the dead bodies of birds, swept along by the whirlwind and dashed against the tower, none of them falling to the ground or losing an inch of their level in the air as they sped onward, until they struck against some high object, which broke their mad and awful journey. Holding on by the shattered casement, Sister St. Luke gazed out to sea. The wind was blowing fiercely, and the waves were lashed to fury. The sky was inky black. The reef was under water, save one high knob of its backbone, and to that two dark objects were clinging. Farther down she saw the wreck of the boat driving before the gale. Pedro was over in the village; the tide was coming in over the high sea, and night was approaching. She walked quickly down the rough stone stairs, stepped into the water again, and waded across where the paroquet boat had been driven against the wall of the house, bailed it out with one of Melvyna's pans, and then, climbing in from the window of the sitting-room, she hoisted the sail, and in a moment was out on the dark sea.

(From "Sister St Luke". Like "King David" this story appears in Rodman the Keeper: Southern Sketches.)



*

The ‘historical novel’ is, for me, condemned, even in cases of labour as delicate as yours, to a fatal cheapness, for the simple reason that the difficulty of the job is inordinate and that a mere escamotage, in the interest of ease, and of the abysmal public naivety, becomes inevitable. You may multiply the little facts that may be got from pictures and documents, relics and prints, as much as you like – the real thing is almost impossible to do, and in its essence the whole effect is as naught: I mean the invention, the representation of the old CONSCIOUSNESS, the soul, the sense, the horizon, the vision of individuals in whose mind half the things that make ours, that make the modern world, were non-existent. You have to think with your modern apparatus a man, a woman or rather fifty – whose own thinking was intensely otherwise conditioned, you have to simplify back by an amazing tour de force – and even then it’s all humbug.

That was Henry James writing to Sarah Orne Jewett (5 October 1901) about historical fiction. She had just published The Tory Lover (1901), set in 1777-78 during the American War of Independence  -- her first historical fiction, and her final book before the carriage accident (3 September 1902) ended her career as an author.  

It was frankly ungracious so far as timing went, but it was sincere. James had indeed a kind of extreme fastidiousness, amounting to a block, about admitting history into his novels. We know from his stage reviews that he loved Shakespeare's plays, responding deeply if not with notable originality. He lived in an era when most novelists loved to quote Shakespeare and other hallowed poets in their chapter epigraphs or their fictional conversations, to build a fictional world that confessed its rootedness in a tradition. In America there was a contemporary glut of historical romance (now largely forgotten), and James wasn't alone in deploring it. But he stood almost alone in the utter banishment from his work of old literature and indeed the words of other writers generally. The past is in fact irretrievable; it only enters his stories when filtered through modern sensibility; silly, touristic, fabricated and at best comic (moonlight on the Alhambra, for instance). His 1903 story "The Birthplace" won't even name the storied poet whose birthplace the Gedges curate, nor does it quote a single word or name from the poet's works. 

Mr Henry James and I are now writing letters to each other, and he always believes in an 'extinct soul' of the last century but I do not. (How could I, when one of my most intimate friends was a Harvard man of the class of '05, and I have seen fashions far back into the 1700's parading up the aisle of our old Berwick Church?)
(Sarah Orne Jewett to S. Weir Mitchell, 23 October 1901.)

But James' observation to Sarah Orne Jewett proves that all fiction, not just historical fiction, is "almost impossible". If a complete reconstruction of another's consciousness is truly necessary, then how can you put any other people into a novel than yourself? You'll immediately run up against the mystery of people who are a little older than yourself, and the still more intractable mystery of people who are a little younger. But everyone's a mystery... A different cultural background, different gender, different childhood, different social class, different health history, different passions... and all the rest... You can't fully know anyone. To people your pages, however, demands not universal knowledge but a sort of happy knack. Fiction is necessarily cheap. It must borrow, adapt, intrude, stage, creatively misremember and distort, reverse engineer, make adroit use of clichés, indulge in mystification, be flagrantly anachronistic, imagine such discourse as never existed, plunder from the intimacies of friends, cover its tracks, and exploit a hundred other tricks to spark the miracle of a story coming to life.

*

"My dear," he said, speaking eagerly, so that she must listen and would not draw away, "my dear, you ask an almost impossible thing; you should see that a suspected man were better left ashore, on such a voyage as this. Do you not discern that he may even turn my crew against me? He has been the young squire and benefactor of a good third of my men, and can you not see that I must always be on my guard?"

"But we must not distrust his word," begged Mary again, a little shaken.

"I have followed the sea, boy and man, since I was twelve years old. I have been a seafarer all my days," said Paul Jones. "I know all the sad experiences of human nature that a man may learn. I trust no man in war and danger and these days of self-advancement, so far that I am not always on the alert against treachery. Too many have failed me whom I counted my sure friends. I am going out now, only half trusted here at home, to the coasts where treason can hurt me most. I myself am still a suspected and envied man by those beneath me. I am given only this poor ship, after many generous promises. I fear a curse goes with it."

"You shall have our hopes and prayers," faltered Mary, with a quivering lip. The bitterness of his speech moved her deepest feelings; she was overstrung, and she was but a girl, and they stood in the moonlight together.

"Do not ask me again what I must only deny you, even in this happy moment of nearness," he said sadly, and watched her face fall and all the light go out of it. He knew all that she knew, and even more, of Wallingford's dangerous position, and pitied her for a single moment with all the pity that belonged to his heart. A lonely man, solitary in his very nature, and always foreboding with a kind of hopelessness the sorrows that must fall to him by reason of an unkindness that his nature stirred in the hearts of his fellows, his very soul had lain bare to her trusting look.

He stood there for one moment self-arraigned before Mary Hamilton, and knowing that what he lacked was love. He was the captain of the Ranger; it was true that Glory was his mistress. In that moment the heavens had opened, and his own hand had shut the gates.

The smile came back to Mary's face, so strange a flash of tenderness had brightened his own. When that unforgettable light went out, she did not know that all the jealousy of a lonely heart began to burn within him.

(from The Tory Lover, Ch 6)

*

Sarah Orne Jewett isn't in The Master -- more's the pity! -- but some of Henry's phrases are, for instance the "fatal cheapness" and the "humbug". In the novel he uses them while repelling his brother William, who thinks Henry should write a historical fiction about "the Puritan fathers". 

But The Master is emphatically a historical fiction, as John Updike pointed out in his review. All the same Tóibín, an intuitively un-Jamesian novelist in so many ways, is thinking about this matter of a vocation alongside his novelist-hero, thinking about its personal costs and what must be compromised and how what we repeatedly experience and what we're always having to deny and even what we dread are somehow what we have chosen, and how easy it is to fossilize into a horrible parody of what we hoped to be, and also how it's no good overthinking it, and that these questions aren't restricted to writing novels or any other vocation but sit unacknowledged at the centre of everyone's life.

In its totally different way The Master is just as personal a novel as Nora Webster. 

(It's a strange coincidence that one of the few unhistorical characters in The Master -- a young and arrogant English MP -- is surnamed Webster.)

*

On Colm Tóibín's Nora Webster:

https://michaelpeverett.blogspot.com/2025/01/colm-toibin-nora-webster-2014.html

On Colm Tóibín's The Heather Blazing:

https://michaelpeverett.blogspot.com/2017/06/colm-toibin-heather-blazing-1992.html

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, June 07, 2017

Colm Tóibín: The Heather Blazing (1992)











Colm Tóibín in 1992


[Image source: http://bombmagazine.org/article/1513/colm-t-ib-n]



Colm Tóibín: The Heather Blazing (1992)


This really isn’t a good choice of novel to give someone as a gift. But read it yourself. It’s about a successful, clever man who doesn’t connect with his family; and it’s desolating. The ending, mildly optimistic with its curious recollection of Dombey and Son (grandfather, daughter, grandson by the sea), does very little to modify the overall sense that one has been wounded, a trap has been sprung on the unwary.

Eamon Redmond doesn’t talk, doesn’t allow himself to think about his past – one thing that keeps us reading on is the feeling that we’re going to uncover a secret but there isn’t really a secret of a simplistic concrete sort, like some unusually traumatic experience. What there is, is the gradual formation of a pattern of life; a powerful success-making driven pattern, but also a pattern that is terribly trapped in its own terms, quite unable to see itself from outside. The book is not a voyage into memory but it is a voyage into Redmond’s mind and all the important things that it doesn’t remember, that it never allowed itself to register properly. I hope the anguish of this paragraph will come across – this is Eamon, back in the bedroom of their holiday home, after his wife’s death:


 


The night when he had washed her in the bath and lay on the bed beside hercame back to him now. He had avoided thinking about it. He remembered that it was a warm, close night like this with moths blundering against the windowpane. He remembered her voice, her voice telling him that he had never listened to her when she tried to tell him about her parents. He had gone over everything, every talk they had in all the years and he could recall nothing. He thought that she loved her parents, he remembered her talking about them in the months after they died. He could not remember her telling him that they fought in the house, nor that her father drank too much. As he sat there now in the night he asked her to forgive him if he had done anything wrong, he told her that he had tried to remember everything, but nothing came back to him, no time when he could have listened to her and comforted her about what had happened during her life at home. He simply could not remember.


 


Tóibín’s complex novel is made out extremely simple words, the ones you speak to yourself. Yet how complex the effect of e.g. that “could have listened”. Eamon’s poor memory, and it’s not any different now when he wants to be forgiven if he’s done anything wrong, is intimately connected to his skills as a judge, the clean slate he maintains for impeccable lines of reasoning. Which is a place of relief. People don’t become brilliant at something just for fun.

Eamon is a fine public speaker, but his communication in private, haltered by a judge’s reticence, is tortuous. He reserves information as a matter of habit.


 


He had learnt not to speak to the Guards; some of them had given evidence in his court over the years and, no doubt, would do so again, and he felt it was better if he did not know them.


He kept listening, more and more sure that he should not mention the story about his father and Cathal Brugha, that he should consign it to the past, to silence, as his father had done with the names of the men who did the killings in Enniscorthy.


 


And to his son:


 


‘You don’t recognize Cathy?’ Donal said to him.

‘Recognize her? I’ve just met her.’

‘He wouldn’t remember me,’ Cathy said.

Eamon noticed that both of them had become hostile. ‘I’ve a very good memory for faces,’ he said. ‘It’s not as good as Carmel’s, but I think I would remember you if I had met you before.’

‘Maybe it’s a guilty conscience,’ Donal said.....

‘Did you see what the Irish Times said about your judgment?’ Donal asked sharply.

‘It’s a funny day now when a newspaper starts making legal judgments.’ He was suddenly angry. ‘But I don’t think that we can discuss the case, if you don’t mind. I’d rather go back to discussing coastal erosion or the temperature of the Irish Sea.’

‘I’m sure you would,’ Donal said.



Eamon is constantly deciding not to tell people things, afraid he will be misunderstood. As we read we learn to interpret these moments as a series of untaken escapes from the pattern behaviour that makes him what he is. Where any of them might have led, who knows? But freedom does not seem a good description of what Eamon has. On the other hand it seems wrong to think of Eamon as exceptionally cold or inarticulate. The book seems quite clear that in his own way, he’s all right, more than all right in many ways. It’s one of the book’s terrible insights.  

Tóibín’s communication, however, is remarkable. The press write-ups on the back of the book reveal for once that this book has been read and has been effortlessly understood (“It is impossible,” says one of them, “to read Tóibín without being moved, touched and finally changed”). No poet would recognize the ease of that transaction with readers of the day. Though the book is too painful to be a bestseller, it plugs straight into the communal or national “we” as endlessly deployed by media commentators.
                                                                                      

This transparent eloquence can make the book easy to under-rate. A second reading does not add much to what came across so completely on the first. And if there is no obscurity of effect, what is there for a critic to do?

What appeals to me throughout is the pacing of the narrative – I notice it without in any way feeling the story less. One great scene is the account of a death-haunted Christmas in which Eamon’s grandmother, so soon to be engulfed by tragedy, is dominant. Another is the punishingly long walk in which Eamon, after his wife’s death, tries to tire himself out and is slowly adjusting. Chapter 11 might be the best and most painful of all, the visits to Wexford for hopeful physiotherapy, and Carmel soiling herself. Nothing melodramatic happens to Eamon in the whole book – this is what we can all expect to go through, and we’ll be lucky if it’s no worse. That’s the other terrible insight.    


 *

On Colm Tóibín's Nora Webster:


On Colm Tóibín's The Master:




Labels:

Powered by Blogger