Wednesday, June 02, 2021

De-digitizing

 

That time of year when there's always a vase on the desk

I've felt completely wiped out for the last few weeks, since I caught a simple cold off the boy (Laura's four-year-old grandson). After three coldified days when everything seemed to be progressing satisfactorily, my body then went into a peculiar, feverish, achy, short-breathed and exhausted tailspin. (I have grave suspicions of the Astra-Zeneca jab messing with my immune response, but let's not get into that.)

During this recess I felt an even stronger desire than usual to do nothing. In particular I could hardly bear to switch on the computer, so a lot of things went on hold. 

But this did lead to one liberation. Since there was no possibility of doing any blogging, and since I wasn't reading anything online, I could gladly give myself up to a splurge of old-fashioned reading, with no need to linger or frame my thoughts about what I was reading. 

So no long musings here, just some sample quotes. 

*

1. Eric Ambler, Epitaph for a Spy (1938). An entertainment that's also a book of great beauty and power. It's set almost entirely in a small resort hotel near Toulon (variant on the "grand hotel" genre invented by Vicki Baum), but it snapshots the whole western world on the brink of war. 

He had been looking out of the window.  Now he turned to me.

'It's a funny thing,' he said, 'how a man can go on for years living with something he feels to be the truth without even suspecting that he hasn't examined all the relevant facts. That was roughly what had happened to me. It was as though I had been living in a darkened room confident that I knew the colour of the walls and of the carpet. Then someone turned up the lamp and I saw that the colours were really quite different and that I had even been wrong about the shape of the room. I had always despised communism. I had written articles denouncing it, calling Marx and Engels windy theorists and Lenin a gangster with a streak of genius. Dialectical materialism, I used to say, was so much cheap rubbishy thinking fit only for pimply youths and half-baked intellectuals. I could be very scathing and amusing on the subject. I thought that I was very wise and level-headed. But the odd thing was that I had never read Marx or Engels. I had the so-called "cultural background of the intelligent European", I was soaked in the neo-Platonism of Bonn. I had not perceived that nothing stinks quite so much as dead philosophies. I was a nineteenth-century man. 

'At first I was very cautious. I was afraid that my mind had been upset by what I had been through and that prejudice was clouding my critical faculties. But I persevered. There was a man there, a German social-democrat like myself. We read "Anti-Dühring" together and became so excited about it that we used to talk all through the night. But what I found so extraordinary was the way it killed the bitterness in me. I was beginning to understand my fellow men, to see the shape of history as I had never seen it before. I read passionately, and as I read I knew that I was seeing for the first time the tragedy of man, his folly and his genius, his destiny and the line of march to it. 

'After a while I started working for the party. The principal activity was getting news into Germany, real news. ...'

(from Epitaph for a Spy, Chapter 13)

[Friedrich Engels' Anti-Dühring (1878): https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1877/anti-duhring/index.htm . Influential in Europe as a relatively concise and popular treatment of Marxism by one of its founders.] 

*

2. Beaumarchais' The Barber of Seville (1775) and The Marriage of Figaro (1784). Brilliant and historically important plays that are inevitably overshadowed by the operas they gave rise to so quickly. From The Marriage, in which the Count's libertine habits have re-awoken . . .

THE COUNT: You are excited, Suzie! Talking to yourself and your little heart going pit-a-pat . . . very understandable of course on such a day . . .

SUZANNE [in concern]: What do you want of me, My Lord? Suppose anyone found you here with me . . .

THE COUNT: I should be very sorry indeed if they did. But you know what an interest I take in you. Bazile must have let you know of my love for you. I have only a minute to explain what I have in mind. Listen. [Sits on chair.]

SUZANNE: I won't listen!

THE COUNT [takes her hand]: You know that the King has appointed me his ambassador in London. I'm taking Figaro with me. I'm giving him an excellent job, and as a wife's duty is to follow her husband . . .

SUZANNE: Ah! If only I dare speak!

THE COUNT [drawing her to him]: Speak. Speak, my dear! Take advantage here and now of your influence over me, an influence that will endure . . .

SUZANNE [alarmed]: I wish for none, Sir! I wish for none! Leave me, I beseech you!

(from The Marriage of Figaro, Act I)

*

3. Anthony Powell, Casanova's Chinese Restaurant (1960). Set in about 1936. The fifth volume in A Dance to the Music of Time, focussed on Nick's contacts in the musical world, on adultery and despair. One of the best, in my opinion (all the better because Widmerpool appears only fleetingly). This extract is from an uncomfortable evening in Pimlico:

'Carolo is always losing keys,' said Maclintick. 'He'll have to pay for a new one himself this time.  It costs a fortune keeping him in keys. I can't remember whether I told you Carolo has come to us as a lodger, Moreland.'

'No,' said Moreland, 'you didn't. How did that happen?'

Moreland seemed surprised, for some reason not best pleased at this piece of information.

'He was in low water,' Maclintick said, speaking if he were himself not specially anxious to go into explanations. 'So were we. It seemed a good idea at the time. I'm not so sure now. In fact I've been thinking of getting rid of him.'

'How is he doing?' asked Moreland. 'Carolo is always very particular about what jobs he will take on. All that business about teaching being beneath his dignity.'

'He says he likes time for that work of his he is always tinkering about with,' said Maclintick. 'I shall be very surprised if anything ever comes of it.'

'I like Carolo here,' said Mrs Maclintick. 'He gives very little trouble. I don't want to die of melancholia, never seeing a soul.'

'What do you mean?' said Maclintick. 'Look at the company we have got tonight. What I can't stick is having Carolo scratching away at the other end of the room when I am eating. Why can't he keep the same hours as other people?'

'You are always saying artists ought to be judged by different standards from other people,' said Mrs Maclintick fiercely. 'Why shouldn't Carolo keep the hours he likes? He is an artist, isn't he?'

'Carolo may be an artist,' said Maclintick, puffing out a long jet of smoke from his mouth, 'but he is a bloody unsuccessful one nowadays. One of those talents that have dried up, in my opinion. I certainly don't see him blossoming out as a composer. Look here, you two had better stay to supper. As Audrey says, we don't often have company . . .'

(from Casanova's Chinese Restaurant, Chapter 2)

*

4. Peter Mortimer, Broke Through Britain: One Man's Penniless Odyssey (1999). Peter (a freelance writer), decided to spend a month walking from Plymouth to Edinburgh without carrying any money.  All his food and overnight shelter had to be begged; creating a daily situation in which people had to make decisions about trusting a stranger (or not). The result is a fascinating but often sobering national portrait. I'm very glad he wrote this book,  -- at the last possible moment before the spread of mobile phones and internet banking would have radically impacted its premiss. (At one point someone invites Peter to use the Internet to prove that he is indeed a bona fide published author, but the service is so unreliable they soon give up.)

 At the hunt kennels in Herefordshire, they get a phone call:

... We'd all seen dead cow meat hanging from butcher's hooks. Most of us had eaten beef at some time. Seeing a dead cow in a field was different. Other herd members stood around, chewed the cud and stared. I noted the cow's swollen udder, milk that would never be drunk.

Peter backed the wagon up close to the corpse and slung the steel hawser around the cow's neck ready for winching. There was a slow whirring sound, and the neck stretched grotesquely from the pull of the hawser. I found myself stupidly wondering if it was painful. Finally the beast was dragged forwards, up the ramp and into the open back of the wagon. The cow was too long. Peter needed to yank it so the head was pushed up against the back of the cab. For a moment it seemed this rearing head was alive, seemed its brown eye, like an open tin of golden syrup, was staring directly at me. Then the head slumped, the illusion was gone. Peter wedged in the feet and bolted up the end of the wagon. We drove off. 'What did the cow die of?' I asked. He shrugged his shoulders. By the time we arrived back, there was already an answerphone query from the vet. Dead cows were a sensitive issue. 

(from Broke Through Britain, Day Eleven -- Wednesday, 5 August)

*

5. Brigid Brophy, The Snow Ball (1964). A novel (her fourth, approximately), but closely related to her non-fiction writing, especially Mozart the Dramatist. The novel takes place in a night. It concerns a masked ball in contemporary London, in which the central characters are dressed as Donna Anna and Don Giovanni. Here are two cabaret performers: 

A man without characteristics hurried on to the platform, shifted the double bass and sat rapidly down at the piano. 

He was followed by a thin girl with thin straight colourless hair to her shoulders. She wore a short evening dress consisting of horizontal black frills which swaddled her tightly to just above the knees. Her legs, in very pale, peanut-coloured nylons, were thin, straight, and apparently unbending -- the legs of whitewood furniture: only the narrow knee cap made a small obtruction in the straightness, like an adam's apple; and when the girl took a step it looked as though her legs had swallowed. Her high-heeled shoes had a narrow, twenties-ish strap across the instep.

She paid no attention to her audience but stood with her back to them while she turned a nozzle of instructions on to her pianist, who sat with his head bent over the keyboard paying, in his turn, no attention to her. 

(from The Snow Ball, Chapter 8)

*

And finally 6., which I'm currently half-way through, Wole Soyinka's The Interpreters (1965), a big and complex novel about a group of bright young Nigerians in Ibadan. I don't feel able to pick an extract while I'm still in the middle of being bewildered by it, so instead here's one of his poems I found online. 


Massacre, October '66

Written in Tegel

Shards of sunlight touch me here
shredded in willows. Through stained-glass
Fragments on the lake I sought to reach
A mind at silt-bed

The lake stayed cold
I swam in an October flush of dying leaves
The gardener’s labour flew in seasoned scrolls
Lettering the wind

Swept from painted craft
A mockery of waves remarked this idyll sham
I trod on acorns; each shell’s detonation
Aped the skull’s uniqueness.

Came sharper reckoning –
This favoured food of hogs cannot number high
As heads still harshly crop to whirlwinds
I have briefly fled

The oak rains a hundred more
A kind confusion to arithmetics of death:
Time to watch autumn the removal man
Dust down rare canvases

To let a loud resolve of passion
Fly to a squirrel, burnished light and copper fur
A distant stance without the lake’s churchwindows
And for a stranger, love.

A host of acorns fell, silent
As they are silenced all, whose laughter
Rose from such indifferent paths, oh God
They are not strangers all

Whose desecration mocks the word
Of peace – salaam aleikun – not strangers any
Brain of thousands pressed asleep to pig fodder –
Shun pork the unholy – cries the priest.

I borrow seasons of an alien land
In brotherhood of ill, pride of race around me
Strewn in sunlit shards. I borrow alien lands
To stay the season of a mind.

 

(Source .)


(The title refers to the anti-Igbo pogroms across northern Nigeria in 1966, precursors to the Biafran war of 1967-70. The poem is located beside Lake Tegel (Tegeler See) in Reinickendorf, NW Berlin. The large lake is set in woodland known for its oak trees.)


Spotted Hawkweed (Hieracium maculatum). Frome, 2 June 2021.


How to opt out of having your GP medical history shared with NHS Digital for future corporate and commercial use (you have until 23rd June 2021):*

https://medconfidential.org/how-to-opt-out/

*True when I wrote it. The date was then put back a couple of months, so the deadline then presumably became 23rd August 2021, though that was never officially stated. Since then, government guidance has become even vaguer, with some suggestion that it's all been put back to 2022. The above link should have the latest information.

Article by Ameen Kamlana:

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jun/03/gp-nhs-digital-data-patients-records-england


Remote Sedge (Carex remota). Frome, 2 June 2021.

Remote Sedge (Carex remota). Frome, 2 June 2021.



Grey Sedge (Carex divulsa). Frome, 8 June 2021.

Grey Sedge (Carex divulsa). Frome, 8 June 2021.



Hawkweed leaves, spotted and not. Frome, 2 June 2021.





Labels: , , , , ,

Saturday, September 26, 2015

Alfred Duggan: Family Favourites (1960)





I found this book, with several others by the same author, on a friend's bookshelves. Intrigued by the unlikely choice of title (from a popular radio show) for a historical novel set during the later Roman Empire, and more so by the drily brilliant opening, I couldn't resist asking to borrow it.

The story is related by an old soldier in retirement (he had been first a legionary and then a Praetorian), called Duratius. He eventually becomes a friend and member of the inner circle of the young and flighty Emperor Elagabalus (c. 203-222 - Emperor from 218-222). When the court implodes he is unceremoniously knocked on the head and given an honourable exit. The beautiful Emperor is killed offstage.





Duggan's conception of the historical novel is close to docufaction. Nearly all his characters, except for the narrator, are historical. He introduces only a minimum of additional fictional events, and these additions are characteristically un-sensational. The principal interest, for both author and reader, is in persuasively realizing a time and culture that, in its details, is a mixture of the familiar and the bizarrely different.

Duratius's judgments, for example, tend to be unexpected. On the one hand they are the judgments of a soldier and administrator of the landowning class, evincing recognizably similar attitudes to those of an equivalent gentleman of Duggan's own time. A noticeably broad-minded version of those attitudes; Duratius is remarkably un-judgmental, for example, about the sexual behaviour of Elagabalus and his minions. On the other hand, he places much importance on matters that are alien to us, such as the importance of duty to ancestors, or the delight of worshipping the tutelary gods of a city.

When Duratius attends a gladiatorial show we are, predictably, appalled at what Romans considered sport. Duratius describes it vividly, doesn't notice what we might find objectionable, but finds it a bit dull, though he admits his seat was near the back and he couldn't see the look on the faces of men about to die. On the other hand, when he first sees chariot-racing (a sport followed in the eastern empire, but unknown in the west) he finds it incredibly exciting.

Here, early in the book, is Duratius' interview with the senior centurion of his legion.

'Duratius,' he said, as I stood at attention before him (every soldier is a good deal more respectful to a primus pilus than to a legate), 'within less than a year you can take your pension and go. I won't stop you. But they tell me you are thinking of signing on again, and that I won't allow. When you apply to re-enlist, someone will ask for a confidential report, and I shall advise against you. I'll tell you why, since the regulations don't permit you to ask me questions. I have no complaint against you so far. You are smart on parade, sober, willing when there is digging to be done, and never the first to run from a tight place. You have never been first in the charge either, but that only proves you are a well-trained soldier. In  fact you would be a model legionary, but for one serious fault. We have followed the same Eagle for twelve years and more, and I am still not certain that you are on our side. There's no zeal in you, either for the cause of Eternal Rome or for our glorious Emperor Caracalla. The next time we charge the Germans I don't want you behind me. So now you know the worst. In a few months you leave the army -- for ever.'
    'Very good, sir,' I said, standing stiffer than ever. If he felt like that about me he could have me flogged to death as a malcontent; when he offered to get rid of me peacefully he was being very lenient.
    'That was the right answer,' he said in a more friendly tone. 'I don't like legionaries who argue. I wish I knew what lies at the back of your mind. You are an educated man and a citizen; in the roll they have you down as doubtfully an honestioris. Yet you carry a sword as if you were a labourer digging a ditch at so much a foot. Everyday you earn your daily pay, and never try to do more. . . . And yet you want to stay in the army. I shall offer one more chance. I have been told to pick a draft for the Praetorians. I have put down your name, though of course you may refuse the honour. Take it or leave it. In either case I shall be rid of you. Either you start for Syria within three days, or at the end of the year you are mustered out of the army, with your discharge marked "no readmission". Which shall it be?'
    'The Praetorians, of course, sir. And thank you for the opportunity.'
    'Very well. Tomorrow you will report to the paymaster, for your papers to be brought up to date. Then take a day's leave, to put your kit and baggage in order. On the third day you will parade in full marching order, with your baggage packed and your paybook signed and balanced. You are not entitled to a government baggage-mule, but if you have a mule of your own the government muleteers will look after it. The legate will inspect the parade, so take pains with your turnout. But you always look well on parade, so that will not bother you. I wish I knew why you are content to be a parade-ground soldier. You have never done that little bit extra that would have earned commissioned rank for a man of your stamp. That's all. Dismiss, and never let me see your face again.'

The historical novel is always an anachronism, and the bigger the time-gap between the date in which it's set and the date it was written, the more problematic this becomes, as we Sir Walter Scott fans are well aware. The most pervasive area of anachronism, though not perhaps the most obvious, is the thought-worlds revealed by how the characters speak. I doubt if a centurion would have or could have framed his puzzlement over Duratius' psychology in quite the way that this passage implies.

But if Duggan wanted to limit the effect of anachronism, then the Roman Empire was quite a good era to work with. At least there was a regular army, which he could assume (when he didn't know) was not too unlike Duggan's own army experience during WWII. Army life tends to be practical, psychological conceptions of minimal importance -- at least officially.

Duratius, or rather Duggan, is obviously proud of the numerous "inside knowledge" remarks that pepper his text (such as the one here beginning "every soldier..."). It was a Kipling technique and I suspect late stories like "The Church that was at Antioch" had quite a big influence on Duggan.

The later and longer part of the book, once Duratius has met Elagabalus and become a court official, doesn't quite match up to the quality of the opening. Flamboyant and outrageous as Elagabalus is, his antics lack dramatic development.  And broad-minded as they are, Duratius and Duggan seem to lack real sympathy with either the young Emperor or his opponents. There's a distinctive but slightly unnerving sense of something missing. Perhaps that something is best described as warmth.

*

But this chilliness may be strategic rather than temperamental. In 1954 Duggan reviewed The Fellowship of the Ring for the TLS, and here he points out the weakness in Tolkien's book of a positive conception of the Good; Duggan specifically mentions romantic love. (It's a positive review, though Duggan had evidently no taste for dragons or trolls. In it he describes the landscape of Middle-Earth in political and economic terms that more recall his own books than Tolkien's: reminiscent, for instance, of the breakdown of Roman civilisation in The Little Emperors.

*

Alfredo Duggan was an Etonian of Irish/Argentinian background. His family were extremely wealthy. At Oxford in the 1920s he was considered a rake of the first order, spending much of his time drunk, riding to hounds, or driving his Rolls Royce to and from a highly colourful Soho night-life. (His brother was the main model for Anthony Powell's Charles Stringham.)

[Duggan, Powell and Evelyn Waugh were all members of the Hypocrites Club during the era when it was transformed by them, along with Harold Acton and others, from a student club devoted to gentle philosophical musing into something a good deal headier.]

As Waugh later remarked, no-one of that generation of silver-spooners seemed less likely to produce a book than Duggan. But after war service and conversion to conservative Catholicism, and a respectable and happy marriage, he began, at the age of 47, to write his remarkable sequence of historical novels.

Northrop Frye described the novel as an intrinsically middle-class form. That is quite right. Nevertheless, its relations with the upper classes are scarcely peripheral: think of Tolstoy. (Not to mention Laclos, Proust, Trollope, James...)

Nevertheless, the category of aristocratic Conservative novelists, in the 20th century, has always been problematic. Not, of course, that it laid an especially heavy burden on the incumbent's shoulders.  A conservative press and public would, it might be hoped, be reasonably well-disposed. And a ruling-class author would possess, no doubt, enviable contacts outside the literary community. Many doors are open to those who know how to behave. I don't so much mean contacts from the toadying point of view, though that's true too; I'm talking about access to areas of life that can enrich your work and that need to be written about.

The problematic aspect is about connecting with the literary community itself. The vast majority of literary people, as is often pointed out, tended to be vaguely or distinctly left-leaning. Left fellow-writers might read copnservative work sometimes, but they wouldn't discuss it seriously. Instead, it would be talked up by newspaper editors, and that's a very different thing. The literary community can be a horrible snake-pit, but isolation from it has serious consequences. You sense this isolation in the later years of Kipling, Waugh and Amis.

Like many clever well-off young people of his time, Duggan himself had a very brief flirtation with Communism. But class told. Powell had taken the Proustian route, Waugh the satirical one. Since conservative authors were apt to be anti-modernist, unimpressed by fashionable ideas, and -  in literary terms at least - non-elitist, another possibility was popular fiction.

It was in the distant past that Duggan found a literary image within which he could celebrate the military and traditionalist values that he was born to.


*

Since Anthony Powell got mentioned here, I'd like to to take the opportunity to recommend this lively collection of school-work (by the students of  Phillips Academy, Andover, Massachusetts) on A Dance to the Music of Time .  

http://www.anthonypowell.org/andoverdance/home.html

It's delightful to see the students responding with such evident enthusiasm and sensitivity to Powell's epic chronicle of the upper echelons; a world such as they will soon be entering for themselves, as many of these elite students recognize. Isn't that the best sort of reading, when you're aware of a book's serious relevance to your own life?  Yet from another point of view it's also a little sad. Is this the future of The Dance: to act as an intelligent deb's manual?

There's a notable paucity of references to e.g. feminism, but in one respect this substantial collection of responses does make a profound if inadvertent critique. Almost all the students read the early books in the sequence with a sort of wide-eyed expectation that Kenneth Widmerpool will at some point turn out to have some good in him, something to redeem his self-centredness, awkwardness and pomposity. It amounts to critical comment because what it suggests is that Powell's own loathing for the Widmerpool type had something unexamined about it, something that he couldn't quite communicate.  The students' instinct is sounder than the author's; they see that it's no great surprise that someone so ostracised has become unattractive and selfish, but that it needn't imply that his inner psyche is corrupted and that he is incapable of loving or being loved.

This collection is hosted on the pages of the Anthony Powell Society. The authors I've mentioned in this post tend to have Societies; Kipling does, so does Waugh. In other words, memory of their work is kept alive by people outside the universities.  That has its good aspects; for instance, dedication and detail. The downside is that it's fans talking to fans; the beloved work tends to be discussed uncritically, without awareness of current research into the wider context of its period, and without feeding into the wider conversations of our own.  So in a way the theme of cultural isolation still continues today.


*


PS (2018)


Perry Anderson's long and enormously readable article on Proust and Powell:


https://www.lrb.co.uk/v40/n14/perry-anderson/different-speeds-same-furies


For all the brilliant insights of Perry's exposition, I remain stuck at the frontier, infinitely entertained but never fully persuaded.  It seems to be so easy to make Powell knock spots off  Proust: but isn't there just a delightful hint of, say, comparing P. G. Wodehouse favourably with Hegel? (What Oxford debater couldn't do that, and yet how little the demonstration matters...)  And it seems strangely pat that the essay, though quite brusque about Powell's early and late novels, finds essentially nothing to criticize in the whole twelve volumes of A Dance. What does such unearthly perfection tell us, both about the kind of work it is and the way it's received? Perry has such fun exhuming and rehearsing passages of A Dance that we hardly notice how his essay elegantly avoids the context of Powell's own times and his own novelist contemporaries. Somehow a question about cultural significance is being sidestepped here. To put Powell (or Wodehouse) in context we really need to be talking about, let's say, .. Lolita... L'Étranger... Awkward, upsetting, difficult, cussed books, but the debates about them, then and now, go on mattering.





Labels: , ,

Powered by Blogger